This is an archive of how Plankhead.com looked before 2014 when it was still Zacqary's personal website. Please go to Zacqary.com for his personal blog and page.

Chad Love-Liberman’s Art4Love is a Fraudulent Plagiarism Peddler

In case I haven’t made it clear over the years, I’m not a big fan of the copyright-lawsuit model of enforcing artists’ rights. When somebody decides to be a dick and exploit the free availability of culture in bad faith, I feel like it’s much better to try them in the court of public opinion than in a court of law. So let’s do that to Chad Love-Lieberman.

Art4Love.com seems to have been around since March 2010, according to the first tweet on its Twitter account. It’s a store claiming to sell hand-painted canvas art, founded by Love-Lieberman as some kind of social capitalism thing. I have no idea; it’s a press release.

Art4Love and the related MarkYourSpot.com appear to have been taken down as of this writing. So let’s Streisand Effect this shit.

Yesterday, Digger artist Ursula Vernon posted on her LiveJournal a link to an article about Love-Lieberman and his “artwork”. She found it odd that this piece was attributed to him:

'Naked Mole Rat Dreams' by Ursula Vernon

It is, of course, by Ursula Vernon. And all of the other pieces in the article are by other artists from around the Internet as well.

Unsurprisingly, as uncovered by Tumblr user Kittenball, Art4Love was similarly fraudulent.

Screenshot of Art4Love.com, captured by Daunt


This screenshot shows Art4Love allegedly selling “Honeycomb” by Julie Dillon. They claim that it’s “Liquid Oil on canvas”, and was painted in 2009.

'Honeycomb' by Julie Dillon


This seems odd, considering the fact that Dillon uploaded the piece to deviantART in 2010, under the category of “Digital Art”.

Hilariously, Art4Love was offering the “painting” with a Certificate of Authenticity.

Tumblr user Daunt has many more screenshots and videos related to Art4Love on her website. Many show more examples of misappropriated artwork, being sold as “original” for high prices.

It’s likely that Chad Love-Lieberman took down his network of websites because he doesn’t want this information getting out. This is precisely why it must. The threat of a copyright lawsuit does not protect the rights of artists to attribution and reputation; otherwise this never would have happened. The exposure of such exploitation on a massive scale is the best hope that artists have to be protected from it. Please, Internets: spread the fraud of Chad Love-Lieberman as far and wide as you can. Make his name synonymous with his crimes, so that anyone looking to commit such things in the future will think twice.

To the artists affected: don’t call this man an “art thief”. Art thieves are skilled, savvy professionals who bypass state-of-the-art museum security. Chad Love-Lieberman is just a plagiarist. And a dick.

    • Shadzii

      It’s Art Theft when someone sells art that is already being sold by the original artists. The artists that created the art is using it to gain a profit to live. This man is selling the art at FOUR TIMES THE PRICE to try and show people up since certain (not all) professional artists make up to only $1500 a year.

      • Shadzii

        This man may not have stolen from me, but I think I more more about art and art theft than you seem to :

        • http://plankhead.com Zacqary Adam Green

          I’m on your side, don’t get me wrong. I’m just saying, why dignify what this jackass did with the term “theft”? Theft requires skill.

          Fraud, on the other hand, is pathetic, sleazy, and cowardly. It’s worse than theft.

          Chad Love-Lieberman is not a thief, because “thief” is too good a term for scum like him.

    • JGervais

      Sickening. I knew that was Julie’s work the minute I saw it. This is goddam unforgivable and unforgettable. It’s RIDICULOUSLY HARD to get out and make money on our art these days and to have some jackass like Chat Love just take it like that? He could have made so much money legitimately if he had just gone through the proper channels and gave the artists their dues. Hope he rots in hell.

    • Nothanks

      Fuck that lowlife asshole

    • http://redbeancookie.wordpress.com Redbeancookie

      “Chad Love-Lieberman is just a plagiarist. And a dick.” 

      XD Agreed.

      There is a drive to get this issue feature on the Colbert Report. If you can, encourage your readers to post there. If we work together, we stand a good chance of getting enough exposure for this that Chad won’t stand a chance of sweeping it under a rug. The Colbert Report thread is located on colbertnation.com, here: http://forums.colbertnation.com/?page=ThreadView&thread_id=28276

    • Mengasuki

      one really has to wonder… exactly how long did he expect this to last?
      the guy really underestimated the internet.
      this man is scum, and i hope he gets sued into poverty.

    • Mengasuki

      one really has to wonder… exactly how long did he expect this to last?
      the guy really underestimated the internet.
      this man is scum, and i hope he gets sued into poverty.

    • angry_deviant

      actually I read somewhere that art4love has been around and ripping off artists since 2002.

      • Smadarm1963

        Art4love started as a legit business in 2001, I was a co-founder with Chad. However, I realized that a) Chad was virtually illiterate, of his books that he claims to have written I know for a fact that they were both plagiarized and he got his assistant to write a bunch of it. b) he was not interested in helping artists and he and the entrepreneur fired me after I expressed my concerns to a potential partner. They then reneged on my severance package and proceeded to change art4love into a site that stole from other sites. Chad has the artistic skills of a 9 year old. I DID NOT HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH ART4LOVE FROM NOVEMBER 2002 ONWARDS WHICH WAS WHEN IT WAS A LEGIT SITE.
        I am happy to help anyone in anyway with a lawsuit, I can testify that this man is a crook with no morals. I’ve seen an article on him where he claims that the rap song he wrote about 9/11 was dedicated to his girlfriend who died in the towers that day. I was with Chad that day and again know for a fact that he didn’t have a girlfriend who perished in the attacks.

    • Brian Sherwin

      Such irony. This guy is scum… but I find it  interesting how artists on deviantART are in an uproar over Art4Love when you consider that copyright infringement is clearly commonplace within the deviantART community itself. Just an observation.

      • http://plankhead.com Zacqary Adam Green

        As is the Internet as a whole, and that’s okay for the most part. If you take a stroll through the rest of the blog, you’ll see that I’m not really a fan of copyright and its effects on culture, sharing, and repurposing.

        Fraud, on the other hand, is an entirely different matter. Especially for profit.

        • mrtamale

          Copyright is an outdated form of ownership control, but what this guy did goes way beyond copyright infringement, it’s just ripping off people for your his own financial gain. there’s no post modernist critique of ownership in art4love, it’s just wrong.

      • evan

        Hi, as an artist within the DeviantART community my reply would be this- art theft is sadly commonplace, but the community responds quickly, & assholes like Love-Libermann get banned quickly.  It’s an entirely different matter when someone from outside the community steals art then fraudulently reproduces it & tries to sell it as their own. Arguments like “It’s the Internet” don’t hold water (not that you said that). It’s not the Internet, it’s pricks with no ethics or integrity with Internet access.

    • Fakir

      here’s chad love photoshop fakery explained
      http://i.imgur.com/NoOeY.jpg

    • Zash

      What I love is that he still has profiles on places like LinkedIn which would give him credibility in the business, though at this point that credibility would be pretty small. Still, makes me angry to see scum like this managing to continue to resemble respectability.

    • Cranstonpeterson

      It is a sad and pathetic situation, when some inexperienced, and untalented, “asshole’ come along and tries to make a “illegal profit ‘ off art that he has no “idea’ how it it was “created’ or what ” motivated’, us (we deviants), to come up with the “thought’ in the first place’…….”Apparently’……”Mr. Asshole’ didn’t consider’…….”Someone would blow him “right out of the “water’ so to speak’……….”Kudos ‘ to the “whistleblower’……”Way to go!’ artistnut64


    Metformin sale purchase Metformin online Lisinopril overdose online Lisinopril prescription Lisinopril Metformin buy Metformin buying Metformin how to buy Alli without a prescription buy metformin cod Cytotec purchase overnight delivery Maxalt no rx in us Maxalt overnight delivery buy Maxalt without prescription Maxalt online pharmacy buy metformin no prescriptions prednisone with no presciption purchase finpecia without rx to ship overnight finpecia by mail buy Lisinopril legally uk Prednisone cheap Prednisone Prednisone buy Prednisone epharmacist buy Prednisone with mastercard Prednisone online purchase cheap Prednisone online Prednisone without rx medications where can i buy Prednisone online prednisone online without prescription Prednisone capsule next day fedex shipping for prednisone purchase Prednisone without Prednisone online no prescription Prednisone cheap overnight fedex cheap Prednisone uk Prednisone canada purchase Prednisone money purchase buy Prednisone on line Prednisone generic Prednisone without doctor prescription purchase generic prednisone online online pharmacy Prednisone purchase Prednisone without prescription where to buy generic Prednisone online without a prescription buy Prednisone where how to buy Prednisone without a prescription buy Prednisone online cod i want to buy Prednisone without a perscription buy Prednisone online no prescription online Prednisone buy Prednisone orderd online without prescription buy Prednisone online without rx Prednisone suppliers Prednisone no prior script Prednisone cheap buy Prednisone Online Prednisone purchase Prednisone without doctor prescription how to purchase Prednisone online without a prescription buy generic Prednisone canada seroquel buy online without rx seroquel online uk buy generic seroquel online cheap seroquel without a prescription buy generic seroquel 50mg seroquel purchase without prescription buy seroquel in usa seroquel 25 mg order online seroquel 25 mg no prescription buy seroquel with visa buy Seroquel 25 mg online buy discount Metformin line buy brand Maxalt buy Metformin drugs order Cytotec overnight buy in Metformin uk what does Requip look like buy Arimidex cheap buy cheap Requip under without rx buy cheap Metformin line (buy generic cytotec canada|order Cytotec overnight|Cytotec fedex no prescription|non rx cheap Cytotec|Cytotec buy cod|purchase Cytotec online without script|pharmacy Cytotec|purchase Cytotec pay pal online without rx|free fedex delivery Cytotec|Cytotec suppliers|Cytotec online overnight delivery cod) (buy genuine cytotec|Cytotec from canada|buy discount Cytotec online|buy Cytotec online with a debit card|buy Cytotec discount|ordering Cytotec over the counter|what does Cytotec look like|buy Cytotec no visa without rx|how to order Cytotec online without a rx|purchasing Cytotec with overnight delivery|purchase online prescription Cytotec without|Cytotec generic|buy brand Cytotec|uk order Cytotec) (buy low cost cytotec|want to buy Cytotec in usa|comprar Cytotec generico|cheap Cytotec by money order|buy discount Cytotec|buy Cytotec amex online without prescription|Cytotec overnight no consult|buy Cytotec with a visa|purchase Cytotec visa|buy Cytotec without a rx overnight shipping|buying Cytotec over the counter|Cytotec no prescription overnight|where can i purchase Cytotec online|buy Cytotec online cod|buy Cytotec online) (overnight cytotec c.o.d|Cytotec purchased online without prescription|order Cytotec no rx|Cytotec sale|buy Cytotec drugs|buy pharmacy Cytotec waterview|Cytotec bestellen|online purchase Cytotec|ordering Cytotec without a script|buying Cytotec|purchase Cytotec online without rx|buy Cytotec with a visa|buy discount Cytotec line|Cytotec order|order buy Cytotec online|purchasing Cytotec online without prescription|order no prescription Cytotec|what is Cytotec|Cytotec suppliers|buy Cytotec overnight|Cytotec oral) (buy cytotec with a mastercard|buy cheap Cytotec on line|Cytotec from canada|purchase Cytotec paypal without prescription|buy generic Cytotec online|purchase Cytotec without a prescription overnight shipping|order Cytotec cheap overnight|purchase Cytotec without rx needed|buy Cytotec no rx|Cytotec ohne rezept|Cytotec no prior script|purchase Cytotec pay pal online without rx|purchase Cytotec online|Cytotec capsule|where can i purchase Cytotec online|buy cod Cytotec) (buy generic cytotec pills|buy cheap Cytotec on line|buy genuine Cytotec online|buy mail order Cytotec|how to buy Cytotec online without a rx|order Cytotec for cash on delivery|purchase Cytotec online without rx|Cytotec no prescription to buy|buying Cytotec over the counter|discount Cytotec|buy Cytotec fed ex|purchase no perscription Cytotec|order Cytotec without rx from us pharmacy) (buy cheap cytotec under without rx|cheap purchase Cytotec|buy Cytotec no visa without rx|purchase Cytotec without a prescription overnight shipping|where to buy Cytotec without a prescription|buy Cytotec c o d|where to purchase generic Cytotec online without a rx|buy Cytotec uk|cheapest Cytotec available online|Cytotec without rx medications|Cytotec non rx fedex overnight free|purchase Cytotec without rx to ship overnight|Cytotec generic|buy Cytotec) (prescription cytotec|buy Cytotec without rx from us pharmacy|Valacyclovir prescription order|purchase Cytotec without prescription to ship overnight|generic Cytotec online|purchase online rx Cytotec without|buy Cytotec c o d|purchase Cytotec without a rx online|online pharmacies Cytotec|Cytotec side effects|Cytotec online no rx overnight|buy Cytotec usa) (cytotec online no prescription|comprare Cytotec generico|Cytotec sale|Cytotec buy cod|Cytotec without rx|buy Cytotec online from canada|Cytotec no prior script|purchase Cytotec on line no rx|buy Cytotec us|Cytotec drug|buy online Cytotec|Cytotec without prescription overnight shipping|buy next day Cytotec|Cytotec no prescription|order generic Cytotec|purchase cheap Cytotec) (buy line cytotec|purchase Cytotec without prescription to ship overnight|Cytotec without rx overnight shipping|i want to buy Cytotec without a perscription|buy generic Cytotec online|Cytotec fedex|order Cytotec uk|where can i purchase Cytotec without a prescription|buy Cytotec australia|buy Cytotec Online|online pharmacies Cytotec|how to purchase Cytotec online without a prescription|buy Cytotec no prescriptions|buy cod Cytotec) (cytotec prescription|order Cytotec online|no rx cod Cytotec|Cytotec usa|Cytotec mexico|purchase Cytotec without a rx online|buy discount Cytotec line|buy Cytotec online no prescription|buy Cytotec in england|buy Cytotec us|purchasing Cytotec with overnight delivery|order no prescription Cytotec|Cytotec with repronex|Cytotec espana) (buy pharmacy cytotec waterview|buy Cytotec line|Cytotec overnight|buy Cytotec no perscription cod|purchase Cytotec without prescription|purchase online Cytotec without rx|Cytotec with overnight fedex|Cytotec|purchase online prescription Cytotec|Cytotec tabletten|100 mcg Cytotec|order Cytotec online with overnight delivery|where to buy generic Cytotec online without a prescription|Cytotec prices|buy Cytotec fed ex|buy Cytotec pay cod) (cytotec cod next day delivery|online Cytotec purchase|buy Cytotec with visa|purchase Cytotec without a prescription online|Cytotec prescription|Cytotec from india is it safe|buy 200 mcg Cytotec|no rx cod Cytotec|Cytotec 200mcg|Cytotec on line|buy Cytotec mastercard|where buy Cytotec|Cytotec uk|what is Cytotec|purchase Cytotec) (where can i buy cytotec online|purchase generic Cytotec online|order Cytotec pay pal online without rx|order Cytotec cash on delivery|buy Cytotec online us pharmacy|buy Cytotec amex online without prescription|purchase rx Cytotec without|purchase cheap prescription Cytotec|where can i buy Cytotec online without a prescription|purchase Cytotec cod overnight delivery|100 mcg Cytotec|buy Cytotec on line without a rx|buy Cytotec cash on delivery|buy Cytotec online without prescription|buy genuine Cytotec|buy next day Cytotec) (where can i buy cytotec without prescription|buy Cytotec without a prescription overnight delivery|buy genuine Cytotec online|order Cytotec uk|order Cytotec cheap overnight|buy Cytotec paypal without rx|order cheap Cytotec online|buy Cytotec without doctor|Cytotec non rx fedex overnight free|purchase Cytotec pay pal online without rx|Cytotec online|where to buy generic Cytotec online without a prescription|generic Cytotec uk|buy Cytotec shipped cod|purchase online Cytotec without prescription|order generic Cytotec) where to buy Requip online Arimidex no prescription with mastercard requip for sale best place order Requip order Requip uk buy Requip online buy Requip online without prescription from canada order Arimidex overnight buy generic Requip canada cheap Requip no prescription buy cheap requip online how to buy requip cheap generic requip no prescription arimidex cheap on online to buy requip order requip without rx buy requip brand where can i buy arimidex without prescriptions arimidex online order requip buy online no prescription buy Seroquel 50mg uk canadian pharmacy Requip buy Requip american express order Arimidex online no prescription buy 0,5 mg Requip generic Requip Requip online without prescription buy Requip online 0,5 mg no prescription Arimidex no prescription needed order Arimidex mastercard buy requip over the counter Requip generic generic Arimidex no prescription buy Requip australia no prescription buy Arimidex brand buy requip where can i get Arimidex without a prescription order Arimidex online no prescription buy Arimidex online no prescription uk Arimidex cheap on online Requip online order buy requip online paypal Arimidex in usa Requip generic 0,5mg buy Maxalt without a credit card buy Maxalt online cheap order Maxalt no rx buy generic Maxalt canada Maxalt side effects cheap Maxalt usa Maxalt order buy cheap maxalt online free consult buy Maxalt 10mg buy Maxalt Online purchase Maxalt uk buy Maxalt Maxalt online prescription buy Maxalt in mo where can i buy herbal Maxalt Premarin for sale generic maxalt online no prescription


    CC0

    It is legal to copy, share, modify, or reuse the material
    published on Plankhead.com for any purpose.
    Please give credit to us if you do.

    To the extent possible under law, Plankhead has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to the content of this website.
    This work is published from the United States.