This is an archive of how Plankhead.com looked before 2014 when it was still Zacqary's personal website. Please go to Zacqary.com for his personal blog and page.

Subscription Inequality: Is This the New Digital Divide?


There’s been a huge reaction in Silicon Valley to Dalton Caldwell’s audacious proposal. He’d like to create App.net, an API-focused feed service (or, “Twitter/Facebook-y social sharing thing” if you talk like a normal person) which has absolutely no advertising, so it can keep the company focused on the needs of the users instead of advertisers.

If you know my work, you’d think that’d sound great to me. The entire point of doing Your Face is a Saxophone the way we have is to combat the “advertising hell” that’s making Caldwell upset.

The problem is that his solution is a paywall..

Okay, quick disclaimer: I am not anti-App.net. I am not trying to cynically dismiss it, and this is not a snark piece. But I have some very serious concerns about its implications.

In order to be a “sustainable, predictable business” (great!) providing a service where “you own your content” (awesome!) which “will align [its] financial incentives with members & developers” (I love this!), App.net is going to charge its users $50 a year. With just 10,000 users, they can pull in $500,000, which should be enough to keep the business afloat. That way, App.net doesn’t have to worry about not having the millions of users that Twitter and Facebook can claim.

Good for App.net. What about poor people? What about high school students without access to a credit card? What about people who are already paying their home Internet bill, their phone bill, their gas bill, their rent, their utility bill, and just don’t want to have to pay another damn bill?

For those people, Caldwell might say, there’s still the ad-supported Twitter. Which isn’t free, by the way, because you’re being advertised to, so you’re giving away your data. I’m with you on that, Dalton. All valid points. But I have a below poverty-line income, so Twitter still feels pretty free to me.

But if Caldwell’s right, all of those ad-supported services are unsustainable anyway. So eventually, you’ll have a choice between a paywalled social networking service like App.net, or just not networking online at all. So all of the people who love and rely on Twitter but couldn’t (or wouldn’t, but it’s mostly couldn’t) pay $50 a year for it will be left behind.

Now, a cynic would say that all those people will be forced to actually go outside and meet people and blah blah blah good old days etc. I sincerely doubt anyone in Silicon Valley would say that. Silicon Valley — rightfully, I might add — believes that social networking services are as essential a utility as electricity and running water. Ad-supported Twitter and Facebook, for all their evils, are doing a much better job of providing essential communication utilities to low-income people than App.net could ever hope to. Especially Twitter, which many of my friends use in lieu of text messaging because they can’t afford a cellphone plan.

However, there’s still that whole sustainability thing to worry about. Even if it were being run entirely as a not-for-profit, App.net would still need to bring in money to exist. In fact, assuming it doesn’t take any outside investors, App.net might as well be considered a non-profit consumer cooperative. But that’s what I don’t like about it: If Twitter is Wal-Mart, then App.net is a snobby organic food co-op in Park Slope. Good for the rich Park Slope people, but East Harlem is still a food desert. There has to be a way to create a sustainable business without being an exclusive club for people who can afford it.

My biggest concern is that App.net is the first of many things like it. I’m concerned that we’re moving towards a world of computing where only the rich and the upper-tiers of the ever-shrinking middle class can afford to participate. More than anyone, I want to see sustainable businesses that aren’t compelled to needlessly grow, but I’d like my friends and I to be a part of them, thank you very much.

I don’t definitively know the answer to this. Freemium works for some businesses (like Dropbox, Github, and Evernote — which are, interestingly, the three examples App.net cites as being proof that people will pay for web services), but I’m not sure how to make it work for a social networking service. The only thing I can suggest is a pay-what-you-want model, which has decades of history in brick-and-mortar social businesses and has been wildly successful online for the Humble Indie Bundle.

It’s still not wildly successful for Your Face is a Saxophone, but that’s more the fault of obscurity than viability. If people like you, they’ll give you money. I just need to get more people to like me. Which is why I don’t put my shit behind a paywall. But I digress.

I really want to see a world full of web apps, services, or just plain old-fashioned sites that aren’t inundated with ads. I also really want to see a world where a low income, a bad credit score, or a young age doesn’t bar you from experiencing them. We can have both, right?

    • Mark Roest

      There are two basic ways to charge variable rates for equal services, depending on ability to pay, and some variations of those. One way is to simply say, sliding scale, $5 [or $1] to $50 per year, depending on what you can afford. The other is to say, $50 per year, and if you can’t afford it, don’t go away — just let us know, and we’ll work something out with you! Provide a link to a form where you offer a series of pay levels, ask what they can afford, provide some ways to pay that much, and say Thank you! We’re glad to have you aboard! Variations include asking for some sort of community service in exchange, and asking for proof of income. Alternatives include asking for community currency instead of fiat (‘hard’ or ‘official’) currency. Where you accept full payment, be sure to say what wonderful things that will make possible (which matter to your audience), and thank them colorfully.
      Following this path leads to community networking, virtual or physical, of all imaginable forms. And this is a Very Good Thing!

      • http://plankhead.com Zacqary Adam Green

        Exactly, that’s what I’m talking about. I’m really surprised that kind of model hasn’t caught on with web startups yet. Maybe it scares VCs too much. (I find it interesting that VC has been used as an abbreviation for both “Venture Capitalist” and “Viet Cong”)

        I’d imagine a sliding scale scheme could actually be more profitable than a fixed price. The lower prices that some of the customers pay gets offset by the fact that there are a hell of a lot more of them. And then you have your superfans who give you thousands of dollars a month or whatever.


    Metformin sale purchase Metformin online Lisinopril overdose buy finpecia over the counter online Lisinopril prescription Lisinopril buy prednisone uk buy prednisone with mastercard (prednisone overnight without prescription|how to order prednisone online without a prescription|prednisone without prescriptions in usa|cheapest prednisone|buy prednisone over the counter|prednisone order online|cheap prednisone online no prescription|buy generic prednisone no prescription|prednisone buy cheap|prednisone generic|prednisone no prescription with mastercard|no prescription generic prednisone|prednisone no prescription needed|prednisone express online|purchase generic prednisone online|prednisone from mexico|prednisone online no prescriptions required from the US|prednisone cheap online canadian pharmacy|canadian generic prednisone no prescription|how to get prednisone online no prescription in 20 days|purchase prednisone online|prednisone generic sale|prednisone buy online without rx|wholesale prednisone|prednisone 40 mg without a prescription|prednisone without rx|prednisone without script|prednisone purchase canada|prednisone cheap online|b Metformin buy Metformin buying Metformin generic Metformin Metformin online pharmacy cheapest Metformin buy low cost Metformin buy genuine prednisone in the u.s. buy discounted prednisone online buy Metformin with a mastercard buy generic Metformin online buy genuine prednisone in the u.s. Finpecia depression women online|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia generic vs propecia|Finpecia cost australia|buy generic Finpecia uk|purchase Finpecia uk|buy Finpecia online prescription|buy generic Finpecia 1mg|buy Finpecia|Finpecia online australia|buy Finpecia no prescription uk|order Finpecia 1mg|buy Finpecia cheap|Finpecia generic 1mg|Finpecia online prescription|Finpecia 1mg generic canada|Finpecia costco pharmacy|Finpecia 1mg india|Finpecia generic walmart|buy Finpecia no prescription forum|buy Finpecia online australia|Finpecia online uk) pharmacy Metformin Metformin order online order finpecia canada where to buy finpecia online buy cheapest Orlistatbuy no prior prescription Orlistat buy Orlistat fed ex purchase Orlistat amex online without prescription uk Orlistat generic purchase Orlistat without a prescription overnight shipping (where can i buy Metformin without prescription|where to buy Metformin online|buy Metformin online without a prescription|buy cheap Metformin under without rx|Metformin buy online in stock|cheap Metformin|where can i buy Metformin without prescription|online pharmacy Metformin|buy Metformin without prescription|Metformin pricing|buy cheap Metformin under without rx|Metformin online purchase|buy Metformin c o d|buy cheap Metformin|cheap Metformin online|buy Metformin online cheap|wholesale Metformin cheap|buy Metformin shipped cod|where to buy Metformin without a prescription|generic Metformin prices|Metformin rezept|buy Metformin legally|buy cheap generic Metformin|Metformin toronto|buy Metformin online without a prescription|online Metformin|online prescription Metformin|generic Metformin|what is Metformin|cost of Metformin|buy Metformin in england|online Metformin buy|Metformin online pharmacy|cheapest place to buy Metformin|Metformin for pets|cheap generic Metformin|Me buy Metformin with mastercard buy Finpecia 1 mg no prescription online|buy cheap Finpecia online|order Finpecia|Finpecia generic walmart|Finpecia online prescription|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia generic online|Finpecia costco price|order Finpecia online|buy Finpecia 1mg malaysia|purchase Finpecia uk|topical Finpecia buy|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia generic|buy Finpecia online canada|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia online india|Finpecia generic 1 mg|order Finpecia uk|Finpecia depression women|buy cheap Finpecia 1mg|Finpecia generic names|legal buy Finpecia online|Finpecia depression women|buy Finpecia 1mg india|Finpecia generic walmart|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia online india|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia 1mg tablets|Finpecia costco price|order Finpecia canada|buy Finpecia online australia|Finpecia dose hair|buy Finpecia online paypal|Finpecia 1mg|Finpecia 1mg for sale|Finpecia online uk|buy Finpecia uk|Finpecia 1mg vs 1mg|Finpecia generic walmart|Finpecia costco pharmacy|buy Fin online Amitriptyline order buy Amitriptyline epharmacist purchase finpecia without rx to ship overnight lisinopril finpecia by mail buy lisinopril buy Lisinopril legally Premarin without doctor prescription Premarin toronto buy line Premarin Premarin online no rx overnight buy Zovirax no prescriptions Zovirax rezept order lisinopril how to buy lisinopril buy finpecia in canada buy Lisinopril cheap online Premarin for sale generic maxalt online no prescription


    CC0

    It is legal to copy, share, modify, or reuse the material
    published on Plankhead.com for any purpose.
    Please give credit to us if you do.

    To the extent possible under law, Plankhead has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to the content of this website.
    This work is published from the United States.